Wed 19 Jan 2011 3:04 pm
I was plenty interested in seeing what Jason Stratton of Spinasse was doing with organic tomatoes at this event last night. But the first question I hear when I say “Muir Glen” these days, I told the organizers, is when their tomato cans will be free of BPA.
The company announced last year that it would have BPA-free cans with “the next harvest,” delighting customers who are tearing out their hair trying to find ways to avoid the endocrine disrupter, but leaving them without a firm date.
Good news: “It’s already happened,” said Julie Johnson, an internal marketing communications consultant for General Mills, which owns Muir Glen. The harvest in question was the fall one, the tomatoes have already been packaged in BPA-free, non-epoxy-lined cans, and “they are literally hitting the stores now”. When the shipments are complete the company will announce the news from the rooftops. So for now, the Muir Glen tomatoes you find at the market might be BPA-free. Wait for the announcement and it’ll be a sure thing (or, at least, as sure as you can be these days). Eden Foods, an early adopter of BPA-free packaging for its beans, has noted that their alternative cans cost them 14 percent more to produce. I didn’t ask Johnson about production costs, but she did say that Muir Glen did not raise retail prices when they made the switch.
One interesting note: Eden Foods now packages tomatoes in glass jars, citing the difficulty of finding BPA-free linings for such high-acid canned foods. I’ll update when I know more about what Muir Glen is using.
19 Responses to “ Are Muir Glen Tomatoes BPA-Free? ”
Trackbacks & Pingbacks:
-
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Rebekah Denn and others. Rebekah Denn said: Muir Glen now shipping BPA-free canned tomatoes: http://bit.ly/hGvv5n [...]
-
[...] Are Muir Glen Tomatoes BPA-free? [...]
-
[...] In company news: Muir Glen tomatoes will be in BPA-free cans soon! [...]
-
[...] tomatoes- Almost all tomato products in metal cans have relatively high levels of BPA (except Muir Glen brand, according to some info I’ve seen) so it’s better to buy in jars or can your own, if you are able.Restock with Quality-Once [...]
-
[...] to BPA-free cans for their tomatoes “at the next harvest.” In 2011 I came across an article that pointed to these being in stores. I apparently don’t shop at stores that carry this [...]
Thanks so much for that info! Hopefully more and more processors begin using them so even those that don’t care will be safe.
Wow, this is huge news! Thanks so much–I’ve been using exclusively Pomi, the Italian ones in the tetrapak, and sometimes they’re hard to find. But Muir Glen is everywhere!
What we need is a full disclosure of what the cans ARE lined with–the exact chemicals–not just BPA free. What these big companies do is make a new chemical by swapping out one hydrogen with a fluoride ion or some such and then call it BPA free, but the new chemical is not disclosed. Take 3M’s Scotchgard. They had PFOSA, announced in 2003 that new Scotchgard is PFOS free, but the new chemical, PFBS is still basicall the same molecular structure with a shorter fluoride chain.
Thank you — and aed, that’s an excellent point. I’ll update the post when I know more.
Thanks for the informative article. As noted in the article you link, Eden Foods tomatoes in glass jars still have lids containing BPA, although there is a vinyl sealer layer applied over the epoxy. I will applaud the day BPA is banished from all possibility of contact with food.
Thanks for this really important post. I often opt for Muir Glen’s organic canned tomatoes at the store, and am really excited to hear that they’re taking this extra step to product consumers’ health. If you’re having trouble locating organic produce, check out our listings of local organic grocers in your area: http://naturalchoice.net/sec3/orgprod.htm
I think Eden is the one to watch as far as a company that’s going the right thing. My understanding is that the BPA-containing liners were the only ones approved for cans containing tomatoes. The fact that Eden didn’t switch to different cans for their tomatoes but is doing glass tells me that Muir Glen’s “alternative” lining is probably not so great, health-wise. Given that it is General Mills, I am not holding my breath for them to do the right thing. Then again, I might be overly-cynical. :)
Hmm. The new Muir Glen lining is still _vinyl_-based, so who knows how safe it is. BPA is getting all the press, but IMO, just about any plastic in a canned item is not healthy until proven otherwise.
Glass jars or can your own, I guess.
Any updates on this? I have been watching the Muir Glen cans at the local grocery, waiting or the sticker or banner that crows “BPA FREE!” (a sure sign they’ve actually made the change) but nothing. And nothing on their web site. Did it actually happen?
I contacted Muir Glen directly and asked whether or not their cans contained BPA. You can see their response below:
“Thank you for contacting Muir Glen about bisphenol-A or BPA.
Bisphenol-A is a component of protective coatings in metal food packaging, and provides an important food safety and quality function in canned foods. Scientific and governmental bodies worldwide have examined the science many times and have concluded that the weight of evidence supports the safety of BPA, including recent comprehensive assessments in Japan and in the European Union.
In January 2010, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration announced another review of BPA. This review in expected to take 18-24 months, and Health Canada and the World Health Organization (WHO) will participate.
Most metal cans in the food industry utilize BPA in the can lining or can lid. Some of our products do, and many competitors’ products do as well.
Muir Glen continues to believe BPA is safe. However, we know that some of our consumers have wanted us to pursue alternatives. We have been working with our can suppliers and can manufacturers to develop and test alternative linings that do not use BPA for some time.
One alternative has proven safe and viable in our processing of tomatoes - and Muir Glen is in the midst of transitioning to cans with liners that do not use BPA. It is an approved non-epoxy alternative. Can coatings used by Muir Glen also comply fully with all applicable U.S. Food and Drug Administration requirements for safe use in food contact applications.
Your views are important to us. Again, thank you for contacting Muir Glen, and thank you for your support of our products.
Sincerely,
Consumer Services”
I contacted Muir Glen and the repsosne I got was that BPA is safe.
I think this story is sadly a PR spin by Muir Gen and they decide not to follow through with BP A free product.
I hope the blog owner updates this story as Muir Glen is now an advocate for BPA
One must keep in mind that Muir Glen is owned by General Mills.
PROTECT YOURSELVES WITH WISDOM. WE HAVE BEEN GIVEN THE INFO ON BPA NOW LET US MAKE A WISE DECISION….AS FOR ME i WILL NOT PURCHASE ANYMORE CAN PRODUCTS…………THANKS FOR THE INFO.
We have been trying to get the Eden tomatoes in the glass jar for over a year now for my market in Eugene Or. from what I have heard from our rep Eden dosn’t dist. them to west coast. are you aware of any tomatoes in glass jar’s available on the west coast or when Eden may distribute them out here? thanks