Wed 17 Jun 2009 3:06 pm
Traditionally, farmers markets in Seattle have belonged to one of two market associations: The Neighborhood Farmers Market Alliance, which runs the granddaddy U-District market and six others, and Seattle Neighborhood Farmers Markets, best known for the Ballard Farmers Market. This year, though, we’re seeing a change. At least four new markets have sprung up: Two are complete standalones, at least for now. Two others are backed by a city institution, Pike Place Market.
What’s the reason for the change? There’s a bit of happenstance — backers of the Queen Anne farmers market, opening Thursday (June 18), organized an independent market when another group bowed out of the market that originated in 2006. Organizers of the Meadowbrook farmers market didn’t realize they might have the option of joining up with a coalition — and their goals are different enough that they might have gone out on their own regardless. But there’s general agreement that a big serving of city support for farmers markets this year, including grants to help kick-start some and a move to make processes like their street closures less complex and expensive, made a big difference. ”We are so grateful to the city…” said James Haydu of Pike Place Market, which is spearheading new “Pike Place Express” markets at downtown’s City Hall Plaza and in South Lake Union. “They streamlined and helped decrease the cost of doing business for a neighborhood farmers market, which is a boon to everybody.”
We’re always personally happy to see a new market, but a new USDA study questions whether farmers markets are growing at an unsustainable rate. Chris Curtis of the Neighborhood Farmers Market Alliance is thinking that there are too many, saying in this post that she’d like to see Seattle study how many the city can support and where to put them. She also notes the growing national issue of “how do we get the ‘farmer’ back into farmers markets,” eliminating the crafts, kettle korn, massage therapists, etc. who are a staple of some.
“We need more markets that are organized solely for the purpose of supporting local farmers,” Curtis wrote. ”Many (markets) are organized because a neighborhood wants a revitalization event or a community wants a weekly food fair. Those are great events, just don’t call them a “Farmers Market”.
Here’s what’s new this year (and one extra: I learned today that there will also be an occasional summer South Park “Market On Wheels” with some great neighborhood vendors):
Queen Anne Farmers Market
Queen Anne, operating at a different location and under new independent management, calls itself the little market that could. It’s not even looking so little, though, with a full roster of quality farmers and producers, and a full schedule of market activities. The market opens at 3 p.m. Thursday; opening activities include a demo by Canlis chef Jason Franey at 4 p.m., and a book signing at 5 p.m. for Mathew Amster-Burton’s Hungry Monkey.
Julie Whitehorn, chair of the steering committee, said that it didn’t feel like an option to let the neighborhood’s market die, or even skip a year, when it was clear the previous incarnation wouldn’t survive.
“It was not simply for all the lofty reasons of saving farmland and increasing the local food supply and improving public health. It was for very selfish reasons,” she said. “We live in the neighborhood, we are raising kids here, some of us, we wanted it for our community. It’s a terrific community builder, it brings people out of their cars and homes and gets them to know each other.”
There were major challenges from the start: One was logistics, whether the association could even navigate the bureaucracy of getting a market going. Whitehorn had been volunteering for the association for two years, and was at nearly every market day for the previous Queen Anne market at its different location.
“I thought I knew a little bit,” she said, but “a lot of it was ignorance, blissful ignorance.” She got a break with “the midwife of this baby,” Karen Selander in the city’s Office of Economic Development. “Karen has shepherded this entire process for us, letting us know what we needed when, what was required, and doing it so cheerfully” despite the overwhelming process.
Another question was whether vendors would be scared away by the prospect of new, untried management. Some may have been, Whitehorn said, but others, including mainstays such as Full Circle Farm, more than filled in the gaps. A lot of familiar faces have returned from last year, and new ones have joined in. At this point, there’s even a waiting list. (Here’s the list of vendors, such as Dog Mountain Farm, Local Roots, Crown S Ranch, and (starting 6/25) Billy Allstot’s famous tomatoes and pastas and sauces from Sorrentino’s. Skillet and Patty Pan will be there with hot food on opening day.)
Another serious roadblock was money. The market association had to raise enough to pay an onsite manager, cover startup costs, and even handle miscellany like a $500 canopy — a challenge even with a city startup grant. The group has raised about $8,500 to date, close to its goal of $10,000.
“The thing about the farmers market that has blown me away is the interest at all levels. We have someone giving us $1,000, and we have checks coming in for $10,” Whitehorn said.
”That’s the power of food.”
“Pike Place Express”
Pike Place Market will run “express” markets from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. Tuesdays at City Hall Plaza, starting June 23, and from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m. Thursdays on Pontius Avenue North in South Lake Union, starting June 25. It’s a new move for the city institution, but Pike Place’s James Haydu says it’s a logical one. “We’ve been here 102 years. The first thing that our charter says is that we are a venue by which farmers can sell their produce. And the way things have evolved in the last 10-15 years, with the absolutely unbelievable growth of farmers markets in neighborhoods around Seattle and the state and country…we’re simply moving with the times.”
Pike Place was approached by the city and by South Lake Union organizers, and decided to take on the two nearby locations. He sees the “express” markets as symbiotic: People who work in the downtown core aren’t particularly likely to walk to Pike Place regularly to buy produce during their lunch hour, he said, and “the idea is, we’ll take Pike Place to them. We think it is just far enough (from the market), it may be a convenience to people.” Once they’re introduced to the vendors and products, he hopes they’ll then seek out the main market on other days of the week.
Logistically, it will be a challenge — unloading trucks on Fourth Avenue after the bus lane restrictions end at 9 a.m., for instance, or figuring out how to park in the high-priced downtown core (Pike Place is trying to work with a neighboring lot to keep prices manageable). Of course, Haydu noted, unloading at Pike Place itself is good practice for a downtown challenge.The City Hall market is entirely Pike Place vendors, while the Cascade market is about 85 percent, he said. The Cascade community hopes to have that market grow into “more of a traditional neighborhood market,” including crafts.
I asked Haydu about the idea of saturating the — so to speak — market for markets. His thought is that as long as there are farmers on waiting lists, it’s hard to say there’s not room to expand — and downtown, he thinks, did have room.”The reaction from vendors was pretty overwhelming that another downtown venue would be great. Farmers are pretty savvy businesspeople for the most part, and they realize there’s a concentration of, say, 15,000 people who work in that immediate area who will traipse over there for lunch.”
Meadowbrook Farmers Market
I wondered, when I first saw the vendor list for this little market at the Seattle Waldorf School, how such a hidden little startup attracted the marvelous Poco Carretto gelato cart. Checking the market out last week, we found the family connection — Poco (and Cafe Juanita) owner Holly Smith is a mom at the school, giving them something of an in. The market is such a sweet addition to the neighborhood, though, it would have merited the cart regardless.
I talked with Tim Love, who is the gardening teacher at the school and the market master, and found that the market’s goal is education — vendors must be willing to participate in that goal somehow, whether leading demonstrations at the market, hosting students at their farm, or other means. Student gardeners aren’t directly involved with the buying and selling this year, but could be in the future. (A non-profit organization runs the market, separate from the school, but it certainly helps to have the connection for a reliable site and a link to the classroom.)
Love hopes the market can serve as a model for other schools starting up markets, and I hope he succeeds. Meadowbrook had an unusually close, community feel to me, with kids taking full advantage of the playground equipment, friends socializing, families walking in from neighboring streets. (The market is small — but it didn’t seem too small to me, and I was surprised to see comments criticizing some of the very things I enjoyed about it. Devra Gartenstein, whose Patty Pan Grill is a vendor there and at many other markets, has a good perspective here.)
As I said, it looked lovely to me:
10 Responses to “ Independent farmers markets growing ”
Trackbacks & Pingbacks:
-
To Market, To Market…
A revamped, community-sponsored Queen Anne Farmers Market opened Thursday afternoon at the corner of Queen Anne and Crockett, replacing an earlier enterprise that had……
-
[...] Although some market managers believe that the field is growing saturated and new markets “cannibalize” existing ones, I think there could be plenty of room for everyone. If we keep spreading the [...]










Another interesting post about markets. I appreciate the comments by advocates of farmers markets like Chris Curtis about focusing on the farmers, but I don’t understand why crafts have become characterized as a negative element. There are crafts that are farm based. There are farm crops that aren’t edible. Farms produce fiber crops for example like wool. Why wouldn’t you want to allow the producer to sell yarn or garments they produced from it?
In our case, one of our crops is basketry willow and our value added products are baskets. We don’t currently sell at markets in Seattle, but I think that both customers and vendors here in Skagit County appreciate our booth at the market.There are a lot of grey areas in determining what will support local farmers, but hopefully organizers of the markets can use some discretion without resorting to blanket rules like no crafts.
Regardless it’s exciting to see the diversity of products grow at the farmers markets. We’ve been selling at Washington farmers markets since 1983.One of the reasons we explored other products was that there were so many westside farms producing similar vegetable crops. I have a recent post on our blog about Farmers Market if readers are interested.
Thanks.
Hi Rebekah–
I left a comment on your previous entry, sharing my experiences at the first few weeks of the Meadowbrook market–I didn’t intend to sound so negative. I love having a weekly market that is close enough for me to reach on foot or bicycle, and overall, it has been a wonderful addition to the neighborhood. My friends and neighbors and I plan to continue supporting the market. Still, I feel that I have to give an honest account of my experience–it was fun, the mission of the market is admirable, the music and food were great…but the market’s website only recently updated the vendor list to indicate WHEN each vendor would be present and it was a disappointment in the first few weeks when some of the expected vendors weren’t there. I also previously agreed with another commenter that the street on which the market is located isn’t ideal–it’s very narrow and lacks sidewalks–but drivers seem to be appropriately cautious so I am less concerned about that now. I hope that the market is able to survive its first season and flourish in the coming years!
Thank you, Rebekah, for an interesting and detailed look at Seattle’s new markets. With the city removing cost and red-tape barriers to markets that fit their definition (primarily farm products), we can expect to see more neighborhoods launching their own “unique responses to the contingencies of time and place” that make for a successful, sustainable market.
And there’s no need to reinvent the wheel! Reach out to the wonderfully collaborative farmers market community.
I want to assure Steve that the Neighborhood Farmers Market Alliance DOES allow farm-based crafts, as does our Queen Anne Farmers Market. Would love to see your baskets, as we are looking for a local source for our “French market totes.” http://www.qafma.org
Thank you, everyone, for the thoughtful comments! There is absolutely a difference between “too many crafts” and “no crafts”. I feel the same way about prepared foods — my personal bias is to have more. As Julie and I discussed on the phone, it’s all balance.
Maggi, thank you for reporting back. I wish that all markets had some mechanism for letting people know which vendors would be at the markets when — I’m frequently disappointed by last-minute changes. Twitter?
I am not surprised that independent markets are springing up and that they get varied and interesting merchants.
It is unbelievable how snooty some market managers/councils are. Some markets have turned into fiefdoms where the powers that be act like they are doing vendors a great favor by letting them sell at “their” market.
However, the vendors who come to our local markets share information. Markets that have managers that are difficult to work with are well known within the vendor community. When other options become available they will gladly choose them.
Good markets, include, Renton, Issaquah, and Kent. No need to list the bad markets, because the merchants all know which ones they are.
A Twitter account would be great - both to let people know who is attending the market on a given day, and also to let us know when the strawberries are already sold out ;-)
The South Park Market on Wheels wants to thank you for the words about our market. The market itself is very different from the other markets around town. Mainly because in South Park and Georgetown there are not really any grocery options without leaving the neighborhoods.
So it’s about time to get some good food in a much needed area. And the great thing about it is we have local vendors, residents selling to residents. We’ll be perfecting our skills and our market and coming back each time stronger and stronger…learning from each one and hope to open every week in 2010. But in a way that is sustainable. So keep us in your view, because this could really be something great. We have been all volunteer management up to this point and our main concern and goal is to bring things not available in this area to this area. So since we are missing eggs and cheese and …we are looking to fill a hole. We’ll have vendors share booths if they need to since we can’t promise the big crowds. We are not snooty market folks and we want to keep the local flavor of South Park alive.
Come see us on the third Saturday of each of the next 3 months. 10am-3pm, 14th and Cloverdale.
I love that the QA market stayed on it’s Thursday date. I was really bummed when I heard last year that it would be moved to Saturdays.
There are also plans in the works for a mobile market (a’la South Park) for us produce starved folks here in Delridge.